Relationship Between Passion and Motivation for Gaming in Players of Massively Multiplayer Online Role-Playing Games

Passion represents one of the factors involved in online video gaming. However, it remains unclear how passion affects the way gamers are involved in massively multiplayer online role-playing games (MMORPGs). The objective of the present study was to analyze the relationships between passions and motivations for online game playing. A total of 410 MMORPG players completed an online questionnaire including motives for gaming and the Passion Scale. Results indicated that passionate gamers were interested in relating with others through the game and exhibited a high degree of interest in discovery of the game, gaining leadership and prestige but little interest in escape from reality. However, some differences were observed with respect to the role of the two types of passion in the different types of motivation. Specifically, harmonious passion (HP) predicted higher levels of exploration, socialization, and achievement, in that order, while obsessive passion (OP) predicted higher levels of dissociation, achievement, and socialization. The present findings suggest that HP and OP predict different ways of engaging in MMORPGs and confirm that passion is a useful construct to help understand different motivational patterns demonstrated by MMORPG players.


Introduction
V ideo games constitute one of the leisure activity sectors that has grown the most in the last decade. 1One of the greatest contributors to this growth has been the massively multiplayer online role-playing games (MMORPGs), a genre that includes those online games involving a computerbased simulated environment through which geographically separated individuals interact by means of virtual representations (avatars) and have the ability to use and create objects.Video games of this type bring together more than 22 million players worldwide. 2iven the magnitude and constant growth of MMORPGs, it is necessary to determine the mechanisms structuring this activity.In this respect, there has been research into player characteristics, 3,4 addiction, 5,6 positive and negative impacts of playing, 7 and personality profiles of players. 8 recent review of the literature has revealed the diversity of players' motives for playing MMORPGs. 7According to Yee, players play MMORPGs to socialize with others, to gain achievement, or to immerse into an alternative world. 9emetrovics et al. 10 identified seven motivations: social, escape, competition, coping, skill development, fantasy, and recreation.These dimensions overlap with those found by Yee.A subsequent study by Fuster et al. identified four intrapersonal and interpersonal motives: socialization (i.e., to make friends and provide mutual support while playing the game), exploration (i.e., to discover the virtual environment and participate in the mythology of the game and the adventures the game offers), achievement (i.e., seeking to achieve one's goals during the game), and dissociation (i.e., to avoid/escape reality while playing the game). 11Socialization and achievement are similar to two of the factors identified by Yee, 9 but exploration and dissociation split up Yee's immersion factor. 8][14][15] One of the main components of the motivation for socialization is that of making new friends, whether through ad hoc groups or through formal hierarchical groups, known as guilds. 16Socialization in the context of a MMORPG involves resolving challenges or quests that the game presents with the help of other people, jointly discovering the features and adventures offered by the MMORPG and, consequently, sharing in achievements made by the guild as a whole. 9,14In relation to this social aspect of playing, Longman et al. showed that social support among World of Warcraft players was associated with fewer negative psychological symptoms and with greater well-being. 17oyle et al. analyzed the multifactorial nature of engagement in digital entertainment games, including MMORPGs, and recommended the use of rigorous theoretical models because previous research tends to comprise lists of features rather than coherent theoretical models. 7he Dualistic Model of Passion is a new attempt to explain how individuals experience inclination toward an activity in which they invest time and energy. 18The model distinguishes between harmonious passion (HP) and obsessive passion (OP).Both types of passion refer to the tendency to engage in an activity that the person likes or even loves and is important to them, to the point of becoming an activity involving identification, in which they invest considerable time and energy.HP involves an interest to engage in some activity through their own volition that does not decline while engaged in the activity.OP, on the other hand, refers to an uncontrollable urge forcing the individual to engage in the activity that one loves.0][21] In general, studies on passion reveal that despite the fact that both forms of passion are usually present while video gaming, only HP is positively related to wanting to play as well as game enjoyment, postplay energy, and self-realization. 22Utz et al. showed that HP was positively related to socialization. 214][25] These studies provide support for the generalizability of the Dualistic Model of Passion and suggest that passion represents one of the factors involved in online video gaming.However, it remains unclear how passion is related to the way gamers are involved motivationally in digital gaming because HP and OP may be activity specific. 24revious studies have used motivations for analyzing gamers engagement and styles of play, 3,25,26 and others have examined the independent effects of the two types of passion, but no studies have analyzed how online gamers with different passions experience different motivations while playing.Also, as Vallerand et al. proposed, passion may influence the contextual-motivational processes that are central for understanding behaviour. 27However, the role of passion in predicting motivations experienced when engaged in MMORPGs represents a key question 28 that to date has not yet been addressed.The purpose of the present study was to study the relationship between passion and motivations for online video gaming.On the basis of the above, we propose exploring how the two types of passion are related to the different motivations for engaging in MMORPGs identified by Fuster et al. 11 Previous research has shown that HP is related to cooperating to achieve common goals in game missions and social interactions, 24 and unrelated to escaping from life situations. 20In light of the above, it was hypothesized that HP would be positively related to exploration, socialization, and achievement, but unrelated to dissociation.On the other hand, in light of the fact that OP is positively related to escaping from life situations, 20 and either unrelated or negatively related to relationships, 29 it was hypothesized that OP would be positively related to dissociation, achievement, and socialization, but unrelated to exploration (see Fig. 1).

Participants
Sampling was carried out for 1 month via MMORPG gaming communities.A message was posted in the general forum of each community that invited gamers to respond to an online questionnaire.There was also a request to forward the post to other players.During the sampling period, a total of 430 Spanish-speaking MMORPG players between 16 and 45 years of age completed the questionnaire (410 men, 20 women).In light of the low number of women, female responses were not taken into account due to their low representation in the sample (4.87%).The final sample consisted of 410 male players with a mean age of 26.49 years (SD = 6.78).Participants had been playing MMORPGs on average for 6.06 years (SD = 3.04) and had been playing their current MMORPG for an average of 2.56 years (SD = 2.29).The most popular games were World of Warcraft (32%), Lord of the Rings Online (22%), Rift (16.6%),EVE Online (11.5%),Aion (5.1%), DC Universe Online (4.1%), and other less popular MMORPGs (9.8%).The average number of hours played per week was 22.38 (SD = 13.82);18.5% spent 10 hour or less per week playing MMORPG, 37.8% spent between 11 and 20 hours, 22.4% between 21 and 30 hours, 10.5 % between 31 and 40 hours, and 10.7% of players spent more than 40 hours playing per week.

Instruments
Demographics.The questionnaire asked for information about gender, age, which game they played, and how often they played (distinguishing weekdays and weekends).
The Passion Scale.The Passion Scale was used to measure passion in regard to the game. 18The instrument consists of two scales and four criterion items;, all of which are evaluated using 7-point Likert items.The criterion items establish the degree to which the player likes the activity (item 1), values the activity (item 2), dedicates time and energy to it (item 3), and considers it a passion (item 4).In the present study, these four items were correlated (a = 0.700).The first subscale (six items) measures HP (a = 0.734), while the second (six items) measures OP (a = 0.853).The Passion Scale has been shown in the past to have excellent psychometric properties. 30In the present study, acceptable levels of internal consistency were found for the Passion subscales.Cronbach's alphas of the subscales are presented in Table 1 and were adequate.

Massively Multiplayer Online Games Motivations
Scale (MMO-MS).This scale was used to measure motivations involved in playing with the different virtual worlds.The MMO-MS is an adaptation of the World of Warcraft Inventory, 11 adapted to each player's reference virtual world.The MMO-MS consists of 20 items divided into four subscales: Socialization (three items), Exploration (five items), Achievement (five items), and Dissociation (seven items).Participants were requested to indicate for their favorite MMORPG and their degree of agreement with each item.Items were evaluated using a 7-point Likert scale.Cronbach's alphas of the subscales are presented in column 4 of Table 1.All Cronbach's alpha coefficients were adequate.A confirmatory factor analysis yielded an acceptable goodness of fit index for a four-factor model reflecting the four motivation subscales: (v 2 (164) = 461.11;p < 0.01; CFI = 0.94; IFI = 0.94; RMSEA = 0.06 [0.000-0.070]).

Procedure
Sampling was achieved by contacting Spanish-speaking forums dedicated to various MMORPGs: Aion-ESP, Rift-ESP, JuegaEnRed, DCUO Hispano, WoW-ESP, Guild Wars Latino, EVE-Online.es, and Comunidad Hispana.Players were invited to participate by a message posted in the general or ''off-topic'' sections of the various forums.The message included a brief explanation of how to answer the questionnaire and an image that contained a link to it.The message also included a request to forward the questionnaire to other players.The scales were adapted to permit implementation using the LimeSurvey free software (www.limesurvey.org/),which allows the dynamic design of questionnaires in PHP and CSS formats.When a participant accessed the questionnaire, they were shown a page titled ''Informed Consent'' that stated that by clicking the ''next'' button, they agreed to participate in the research and answer the questions.This page also informed the participants that their responses would remain anonymous and that they could stop their participation voluntarily at any time without penalty.Duplicate participation was controlled for via ''cook-ies'' and IP filtering.Answers were recorded in a MySQL database hosted on the servers provided by LimeSurvey.Responses were imported from the LimeSurvey host servers to a database compatible with the statistical packages IBM SPSS Statistics v19.0 (IBM Corp., Armonk, NY) and EQS 6.1 (Multivariate Software, Inc., Encino, CA).Path analysis, with maximum likelihood estimation, was used to test the hypothesized model.Conventional criteria were used to assess the fit of the hypothesized model to the observed data.Adequate fit was inferred when TLI and CFI were > 0.95, RMSEA was < 0.06, and SRMR was < 0.08. 31

Results
The means and standard deviations as well as the intercorrelations of the measures are displayed in Table 1.HP and OP correlated together only weakly.In general, gamers scored higher on HP than on OP.
The hypothesized model was tested by a path analysis where HP was hypothesized to be positively related to exploration, relationships, and achievement but unrelated to dissociation, while OP was hypothesized to be positively related to dissociation, achievement, and socialization but unrelated to exploration.In addition, covariances were freed between the two types of passion and among all motivations except exploration and socialization on the one hand and dissociation on the other.Due to the crosssectional design and the potential for multiple models to provide adequate fit to the data, a theoretically viable alternative model was previously tested.In this alternative model, HP is a positive predictor of socialization and exploration, two motives with positive consequences, and OP is a positive predictor of achievement and dissociation, which are expected to be motives with negative consequences.In this model, all the motives are assumed to be correlated.Additionally, a replication of the proposed model was carried with World of Warcraft players and players of the other MMORPGs.
Results are presented in Figure 2. Fit indexes demonstrated that the theoretically alternative model did not show an adequate fit.However, the hypothesized model showed an adequate fit to the data (v 2 = 4.591 (4); p > 0.05; CFI = 0.99; GFI = 0.99; NFI = 0.99; NNFI = 0.99; RMSEA = 0.01 [0.000-0.079]).Fit indexes for the hypothesized model in separate samples indicate that the model fits well for different games (see Table 2).
The R 2 statistic indicated that 11.2% of the variance in Socialization, 19.2% of the variance in Exploration, 16.7%

Discussion
Vallerand et al. proposed that passion may influence the contextual-motivational processes that are central for understanding behavior, 27 and Wang et al. concluded that passion could help our understanding of motivation in digital gaming. 24However, to date, studies have not analyzed how passions may affect people's motivations when engaged in playing MMORPGs.Thus, the major goal of the present study was to analyze how passion relates to motives for playing MMORPGs.As expected, results indicated that HP was mainly positively related to exploration and socialization as well as achievement.On the other hand, OP was mainly related to dissociation and achievement and weakly to socialization.
These results suggest that both constructs-motivation and passion-can be integrated into an explanatory model of gaming behavior, in which HP and OP guide the various motivations experienced while playing online gaming.Thus, as expected, it was found that exploration, socialization, and achievement are motivations triggered by HP, whereas those of dissociation, achievement, and, to a lesser extent, socialization are experienced when engaging in MMORPGs out of OP.So, as expected, HP facilitates the experience of more adaptive forms of motivation, while OP leads to the experience of both adaptive (achievement and socialization) and less adaptive (dissociation) forms of motivation.
These findings are in line with those of Wang et al., who concluded that those players who form part of a guild oriented toward social interaction are less likely to develop an addiction to playing, something that is associated with an OP. 24Although MMORPGs represents an open experience in which players direct their activity toward challenges that can be either casual or more achievement oriented, 12,32 the game is usually developed within the limits resulting from the motivations implicit in its design-mainly socialization and exploration, with achievement being secondary to these.It may thus be inferred that forms of playing motivated by socialization and exploration predict positive consequences. 11Unsurprisingly, Longman et al. concluded that socialization in playing MMORPGs leads to greater wellbeing. 17he relationship between OP and socialization can be explained by a phenomenon observed by Shen and Williams who found that despite socialization in MMORPG being a positive factor, in some cases it could develop to a point where players preferred online encounters to ''face-to-face'' contact. 33In this way, users avoid physical relations and satisfy their social needs through a virtual world.Moreover, Snodgrass et al. claim that dissociation is part of MMORPGs through what they term ''technologies of absorption,'' 34 and which may lead to either positive or negative effects depending on the context in which the activity is engaged.][37] The present findings indicate that HP and OP both help to predict different ways of engaging in MMORPGs.Thus, the results are in line with those of Stoeber et al. and Wang and Chu, 20,23 and confirm that the Dualistic Model of Passion helps to differentiate between two types of players who are equally passionate about the game but who show different motivational patterns and, as result, who experience different consequences.HP is related to motivational forces to engage voluntarily in an activity, where the player can control their level of participation, display a flexible persistence, and experience adaptive outcomes.OP can generate excitement derived from engagement, but becomes overpowering and difficult to regulate. 38As a consequence, OP has been shown to be associated with personal dissatisfaction, psychological problems, behavioral problems, low self-realization, and physical problems. 19,22Thus, OP for online gaming promotes online relationships but poorer outcomes. 21owever, our results support previous findings that have evidenced the adaptive role of HP. 39 As Curran et al. 40

PASSION AND MOTIVATION IN MMORPGS
argued, this can be understood in the sense of its potential for mitigating negative effects.So, interventions could then focus on using MMORPGs in coexistence with other socialization and leisure activities.With regard to OP, it seems to be related to maladaptive forms of gaming, dedicating a high number of hours with the main interest being to escape from reality.Thus, it that is not the number of hours played per se that may be problematic with respect to MMORPGs but the passion that fuels game playing.Given that features of the subjective experience of gaming, such as presence, flow, and immersion, may lead to negative outcomes, 7,41 their relationship with OP should be analyzed.Moreover, because players who develop an OP for the game appear to be unable to regulate the time they spend playing, in line with Utz et al.'s suggestion, future research should assess whether OP represents a screening tool for problematic forms of play. 21We note that these results have been obtained on a sample of players of different MMORPGs, which would validate the usefulness of the Dual Model of Passion beyond specific games.
Certain limitations of the present study deserve to be mentioned.One is that the data were cross-sectional.Clearly, there is a need for longitudinal studies charting the evolution of game playing motivation as a function of passion.Second, it is not known whether the players with high scores for OP were really addicted to the game.Given that the differentiation between gaming addiction and high engagement is still not clear, future studies should focus on this issue. 42Thus, future research would do well to relate OP and addiction in clinical samples.
Moreover, another limitation of this study was the fact that females could not be taken into account in the data analyses.Other researchers have determined that the video game phenomenon is profoundly gendered, and the number of male players is significantly greater than that of women. 43oreover, previous research with players has shown that these differences are even greater among Spanish-speaking MMORPG players, suggesting that this is due to the late arrival of the MMORPG genre to the Spanish video game market. 3Future research should take into consideration achieving a representative female sample.
In conclusion, the passion-motivation model that was empirically substantiated in the present research proposes a framework and a context through which the gamer and his activity can be understood in a more comprehensive fashion.This research also suggests that the Dualistic Model of Passion may be useful in designing programs to promote a more adaptive way to engage in MMORPGs and, in turn, to experience adaptive outcomes from one's engagement in such games.

FIG. 1 .
FIG. 1. Hypothesized path model of massively multiplayer online role-playing game (MMORPG) playing in terms of motivations and passions.
of the variance in Achievement, and 50.1% of the variance in Dissociation were explained by the model.As hypothesized, significant paths ( p < 0.001) were observed between HP and exploration (b = 0.381), socialization (b = 0.190), and achievement (b = 0.235).On the other hand, significant paths were obtained between OP and dissociation (b = 0.785), achievement (b = 0.322), and socialization (b = 0.084).

haveFIG. 2 .
FIG. 2. Diagram of the conceptual model and the results of path analysis.

Table 1 .
Descriptive Statistics and Correlation Coefficients for the Massively Multiplayer Online Games Motivations Scale (MMO-MS) and the Passion Scale

Table 2 .
Fit of Path Models Note.M1: In this model, HP have a direct pathway to exploration and socialization, and OP to achievement and dissociation; the four motives are intercorrelated.M2: The proposed model.M3: The proposed model tested only with World of Warcraft players (n = 131).M4: The proposed model tested only with players of other MMORPGs (n = 279).*p < 0.05; ns, not significant.