This is the accepted version of the journal article: Bartolini-Lucenti, Saverio; Madurell-Malapeira, Joan; Rook, Lorenzo. «The carnivorans from Cava Monticino (Faenza, Italy; Messinian) revisited». Historical Biology, (February 2022). DOI 10.1080/08912963.2022.2042806 This version is available at https://ddd.uab.cat/record/257658 under the terms of the license Supplementary Material of “Remarks on the Messinan carnivores from Brisighella (Faenza, Italy)” by Bartolini-Lucenti S., Madurell-Malapeira J., Rook L. . Measurements Used in the analysis Table S1 Resuming table of measurements used in the analysis of Felis christoli from Cava Monticino. Species Site Cat. Number m1 L m1W Reference C. caracal Living RMCA12141 10.5 5.2 - C. caracal Living RMCA12141 12 5.5 - C. caracal Living RMCA19238 11.4 5.8 - C. caracal Living RMCA19238 11.8 5.5 - C. caracal Living RMCA23450 12.6 6.2 - C. caracal Living RMCA23450 14 6.1 - C. caracal Living RMCA28707 12.5 5.7 - C. caracal Living RMCA28707 12.3 5.8 - C. caracal Living RMCA31154 10.5 5.1 - C. caracal Living RMCA31154 10.9 5.4 - C. caracal Living RMCA33297 11.5 5.1 - C. caracal Living RMCA33297 11.7 5.3 - F. attica Pikermi AMPG PG 01/107 10.2 4.3 - F. attica Pikermi AMPG PG 01/108 10.3 4.3 - F. attica Pikermi BSPM-PIK-AS II.116 11 5 - F. attica Pikermi MGL 482 S 11.1 4.4 - F. attica Pikermi PIK 3232 right 10.4 4 - F. christoli Cava Monticino MSF 90 13 5.3 - F. christoli Montpellier MP338 12.9 5.7 Ficcarelli and Torre 1975 F. christoli Venta del Moro NMC19 12.4 5.2 Morales and Aguirre 1976 F. sylvestris Borsuka Cave MF/6964 8.9 4 - F. sylvestris Jaurens CBUL 301097 10.2 4.3 - F. sylvestris Jaurens CBUL 301153 8.2 3.9 - F. sylvestris Kudaro 1 ZIN 36464 9.3 4.1 Baryshnikov 2011 F. sylvestris Kudaro 1 ZIN 36465 8.2 3.3 Baryshnikov 2011 F. sylvestris Kudaro 1 ZIN 36467 8.6 3.9 Baryshnikov 2011 F. sylvestris Lunel Viel s.n. 8 3.8 - F. sylvestris Lunel Viel s.n. 8.6 3.8 - F. sylvestris Petralona PEC 1604 9.2 4 - F. sylvestris Petralona PEC 1605 9.7 4.6 - F. sylvestris Tighennif TER-2027 8.4 3.5 Geraads 2016 F. sylvestris Tighennif TER-2028 8.4 3.6 Geraads 2016 L. issiodorensis Almanzora CA-101 13.6 5.9 - L. issiodorensis Cueva Victoria Carnivora 4 14.5 5.8 - L. issiodorensis Cueva Victoria Carnivora 9 13.2 5.7 - L. issiodorensis Etouaires Prr 200 15.3 6.6 - L. issiodorensis Etouaires Prr 200 14.7 6.5 - L. issiodorensis Etouaires Prr204 15.2 6.8 - L. issiodorensis Etouaires Prr205 14.6 6.4 - L. issiodorensis Etouaires Prr205 14.5 6.7 - L. issiodorensis Etouaires Prr24 15.3 6.7 - L. issiodorensis Etouaires Prr411 16.3 6.9 - L. issiodorensis Etouaires Prr411 16.3 6.7 - L. issiodorensis Etouaires Prr496 14.2 6.6 - L. issiodorensis La Puebla de Valverde LPV98'-337-16 13.14 5.42 - L. issiodorensis La Puebla de Valverde s.n. 15.3 6.7 - L. issiodorensis Matassino IGF 12969 13.22 6.3 - L. issiodorensis Olivola IGF 4396 15.3 6.7 - L. issiodorensis Olivola IGF 4396 15.3 6.9 - L. issiodorensis Pardines IGF15071 15.9 6.7 - L. issiodorensis Pardines L.P.150 16.1 6.4 - L. issiodorensis Pardines? IGF15072 14.2 6.1 - L. issiodorensis Perrier IGF12777 15.5 6.8 - L. issiodorensis Perrier IGF12777 15.4 6.7 - L. issiodorensis Saint-Vallier 20 161872 15.7 6.5 - L. issiodorensis Saint-Vallier 20 161873 15.1 6.4 - L. issiodorensis Saint-Vallier 20 161880 15.8 7.1 - L. issiodorensis Saint-Vallier 20 161881 14.3 6.2 - L. issiodorensis Saint-Vallier 20 161884 13.8 5.7 - L. issiodorensis Saint-Vallier 20 161886 15.4 7.2 - L. issiodorensis Saint-Vallier 20 161887 14.8 7.3 - L. issiodorensis Serrat d'en Vaquer IGF 13771 13.9 7.1 - Species Site Cat. Number m1 L m1W Reference L. issiodorensis Serrat d'en Vaquer IGF 13771 14.9 6.9 - L. issiodorensis Untermassfeld IQW 1980/16573 14.1 5.5 - L. issiodorensis Untermassfeld IQW 1980/16573 (Mei.16094) 14,1+ 5.7 - L. issiodorensis Untermassfeld IQW 1994/24691 13 6 - L. issiodorensis Untermassfeld IQW 1994/24691 (Mei. 24220) 13.1 5.9 - L. issiodorensis Valdarno IGF 891 13.74 6.11 - L. issiodorensis Valdarno IGF891 13.4 6.1 - L. issiodorensis Valdarno IGF893 12.3 5.8 - L. issiodorensis Valdarno IGF893 13.5 5.4 - L. issiodorensis Valdarno IGF896 14.2 6.1 - L. issiodorensis Valdarno IGF898 13.1 6.1 - L. issiodorensis Valdarno V.A.1164 14.4 6.1 - L. lynx Extant 8158 13.6 6.3 - L. lynx Extant 8234 16.4 7.5 - L. lynx Extant 8632 14.1 6.4 - L. lynx Extant 8634 14.8 6.7 - L. lynx Extant 8692 14.8 6.5 - L. lynx Extant 8864 15.7 6.8 - L. lynx Extant "5000426" 14 6.5 - L. lynx Extant C.1250 16.4 6.8 - L. lynx Extant C.147 14.4 6.8 - L. pardinus Cau d'en Borràs MGB-V-6067 13.1 5.67 - L. pardinus Cova Toll MGB-V1261 13.89 5.62 - L. pardinus Cova Toll MGB-V857 13.58 5.71 - L. pardinus Cova Toll MGB-V858 14.19 6.39 - L. pardinus Cova Toll MGB-V860 14.28 5.9 - L. pardinus Cova Toll MGB-V9276 13.79 5.57 - L. pardinus Extant 8800 12.4 5.4 - L. pardinus Extant 8865 13 5.1 - L. pardinus Turó del Moro MGB-V1374 12.64 5.45 - L. pardinus Turó del Moro MGB-V1374 12.59 5.71 - L. rufus Extant 6111 10.8 4.9 - L. rufus Extant 7980 11.9 4.5 - L. rufus Extant 30995 11.2 5.1 - L. rufus Extant 30995 11.8 4.9 - L. rufus Extant B-8 10.6 5.2 - L. rufus Extant B-8 10.7 4 - L. rufus Extant B-8a 10.8 4.7 - L. rufus Extant C.1816 10.2 4.1 - L. rufus Extant C.4118 10.6 4.4 - L. rufus Extant C.573 10.8 5 - L. rufus Extant PED-019-1 10.1 4.9 - L. rufus Extant PED-019-1 10.5 4.6 - L. rufus La Brea Pit 16 12 5.4 - L. rufus La Brea Pit 16 10.8 4.1 - L. rufus La Brea Pit 16 X9077 9.5 4.8 - L. rufus La Brea Pit 16 X-9078 9.74 4.64 - L. rufus La Brea Pit 16 X9080 9.9 4.7 - L. rufus La Brea Pit 16 X-9081 12.4 5.5 - L. rufus La Brea Pit 16 X-9492 10.1 4.4 - L. rufus La Brea Pit 3+4 X-9082 13.38 5.43 - L. rufus La Brea Pit 3+4 X9262 12.3 5.21 - L. rufus La Brea Pit 3+4 X9490 11.8 5.21 - L. rufus La Brea Pit 4 X-9083 11.5 5.4 - L. rufus La Brea X9491 10.9 5.3 - L. vallesiensis Batallones B-2074 (45) left 9.38 3.96 Salesa et al. 2012 L. vallesiensis Batallones B-3319 left 9.46 4.06 Salesa et al. 2012 L. vallesiensis Batallones B-3319 right 9.11 3.98 Salesa et al. 2012 L. vallesiensis Batallones BAT-1’01 D6-65 right 9.28 3.93 Salesa et al. 2012 L. vallesiensis Batallones BAT-1’02 D6-57 left 9.41 3.94 Salesa et al. 2012 L. vallesiensis Batallones BAT-1’03 D4-265 left 10.48 4.12 Salesa et al. 2012 L. vallesiensis Batallones BAT-1’03 D6-37 right 9.39 3.94 Salesa et al. 2012 Table S2 Resuming table of mean values of upper and lower teeth of Plioviverrops used in the log-ratio analysis of Figure 4. M1 W M2 W m1 W m2 W P3 W P4 W p3 W p4 W M1 L M2 L m1 L m2 L P3 L P4 L p3 L pL Species Reference P. faventinus 9.0 5.7 11.5 8.0 7.2 9.8 5.6 7.5 9.0 4.1 9.8 4.7 11.1 5.3 7.4 5.3 Present work P. gaudryi 10.0 6.4 8.0 3.8 De Beaumont and Mein 1972 P. gervaisi 9.9 5.9 8.3 4.0 4.6 4.2 De Beaumont and Mein 1972 P. guerini 8.6 4.1 13.4 7.4 6.7 10.7 4.8 8.0 7.8 3.4 9.0 3.9 11.6 5.2 6.3 4.5 Alcalà 1994 P. orbignyi 6.9 3.6 9.6 6.2 5.9 7.4 4.3 5.8 6.9 3.0 7.7 3.7 9.0 4.3 5.3 3.9 Koufos 2011 P. cf. orbignyi 6.4 3.3 9.1 5.8 5.6 7.4 4.2 5.5 Sen and Sarraç 2018 Table S3 Resuming table of measurements used in the analysis of Lycyaena chaeretis from Cava Monticino. Species Site Cat. Number m1 L m1 W References Hyaenictis aff. almerai Ronda Oest Sabadell D IPS62078 25.90 13.10 - Hyaenictis graeca Pikermi MNHN.F.PIK3275 26.6 11.3 - Hyaenictis hendeyi Langebaanweg SAM PQ-L20990 26.9 12.3 Werdelin et al. 1994 Hyaenictis hendeyi Langebaanweg SAM PQ-L21000 25 11.7 Werdelin et al. 1994 Hyaenictis hendeyi Langebaanweg SAM PQ-L40224 24.4 12.1 Werdelin et al. 1994 Hyaenictis hendeyi? Langebaanweg SAM PQ-L21788 25.4 12 Werdelin et al. 1994 Hyaenictis hendeyi? Langebaanweg SAM PQ-L21792 26.2 11.8 Werdelin et al. 1994 Hyaenictitherium wongii Akkasadagi AKK-115 20.20 9.50 De Bonis and Koufos 1991 Hyaenictitherium wongii Greece LGPUT-RZ1-2 20 9 Koufos 2021 Hyaenictitherium wongii Greece LGPUT-VTK-37b 19.4 9 Koufos 2021 Hyaenictitherium wongii Greece MNHNP-PIK-3010 18.2 9.1 Koufos 2021 Hyaenictitherium wongii Greece MNHNP-PIK-3377 18.8 8.9 Koufos 2021 Hyaenictitherium wongii Greece MNHNP-PIK-3378 18.6 9.2 Koufos 2021 Hyaenictitherium wongii Greece MNHNP-SLQ-930 21 9 Koufos 2021 Hyaenictitherium wongii Greece NHMA-MTLA-2 18.2 9 Koufos 2021 Hyaenictitherium wongii Greece NHMA-MTLA-266 20.7 9.8 Koufos 2021 Hyaenictitherium wongii Greece NHMA-MTLA-468 21.8 9.5 Koufos 2021 Hyaenictitherium wongii Greece NHMA-MTLB-1 20.5 9.3 Koufos 2021 Hyaenictitherium wongii Greece NHMW-SAM- 20 8.1 Koufos 2021 Hyaenictitherium wongii Greece NHMW-SAM- 18.3 9.2 Koufos 2021 Hyaenictitherium wongii Greece NHMW-SAM-A. 20 8.5 Koufos 2021 Hyaenictitherium wongii Greece PIUW-SAM 18.6 8.9 Koufos 2021 Hyaenictitherium wongii Greece PIUW-SAM-1889-V,3-3 20.2 9.3 Koufos 2021 Hyaenictitherium wongii Höwenegg Hö 1040 19.90 9.10 De Beaumont 1986 Lycyaena aff. chaeretis Fuentiduena SB 24.50 10.40 - Lycyaena cf. chaeretis Cava Monticino MSF 87 25.80 12.10 - Lycyaena chaeretis Cerro de la Gariata CD-921 25.7 12.3 Alcalà 1994 Lycyaena chaeretis Pikermi BM M8979 21.70 10.30 Koufos 2021 Lycyaena chaeretis Pikermi 23.70 9.70 Koufos 2021 Lycyaena chaeretis Samos AMNH 100070 23.70 10.10 Koufos 2021 Lycyaena chaeretis Samos AMNH 100073 22.10 9.20 Koufos 2021 Lycyaena chaeretis Samos Lausanne 273 22.00 8.50 Koufos 2021 Lycyaena chaeretis Samos ML 273 21.80 9.70 Koufos 2021 Lycyaena crusafonti Bled Douarah T1173 24.00 11.30 - Lycyaena crusafonti Bled Douarah T3292 24.60 12.40 - Lycyaena crusafonti Bled Douarah, Loc. 17 T-1173 24.00 11.30 - Lycyaena crusafonti Bled Douarah, Loc. 17 T-3292 24.60 12.40 - Lycyaena dubia Chao Chia Kou F:AM 56-L560 23.10 10.00 - Lycyaena dubia Hsiao Kou Shan F:AM 38-B296 22.40 9.00 - Lycyaena dubia Nan Ho F:AM 69-B848 23.00 9.20 - Lycyaena macrostoma Dhok Pathan D136 23.00 10.90 - Lycyaena rhomboideae Pestlorinc Hungary 27.3 13.9 Werdelin 1999 Thalassictis certa La Grive Saint Alban MHNL LGr 1330 17.80 8.90 Peignè 2016 Thalassictis montadai Çandir EUNHM PV-2675 23.94 9.22 Peignè 2016 Thalassictis montadai Hostalets de Pierola IPS-2074 20.50 9.00 Peignè 2016 Thalassictis montadai Przeworno 2 PAS MF/1992/91 20.30 10.00 Peignè 2016 Thalassictis montadai San Quirze 20.00 10.00 Peignè 2016 Thalassictis montadai Sinap AS.92.463 & 464 23.10 10.30 Peignè 2016 Thalassictis montadai Yeni Eskihisa BSP1967 VI 772 23.30 10.15 Peignè 2016 Thalassictis proava Chinji GSI D 126 15.60 8.10 Peignè 2016 Thalassictis proava Chinji GSI D 233 16.50 7.80 Peignè 2016 Thalassictis robusta Don-Durkheim SMF DD 3495 16.00 7.00 Peignè 2016 Thalassictis robusta Höwenegg Hö 27 17.20 7.80 Peignè 2016 Thalassictis robusta Kishinev 17.40 8.00 Peignè 2016 Thalassictis spelaea Akkasadagi AKK-11 18.60 8.80 De Bonis 2005 Thalassictis spelaea Gritsev 17.29 8.52 Peignè 2016 Table S4 Resuming table of mean values of m1 length and width of Eucyon spp. used in the analysis of Eucyon monticinensis from Cava Monticino. Species Site Cat. Number m1 L m1 W E. adoxus La Calera FM 144223 17.5 6.5 E. adoxus La Calera FM 144224 18 7.2 E. adoxus Roussillon RSS 45 18 7.6 E. cipio Los Mansuetos 21.3 8 E. davisi Bird Bone Quarry F:AM 76204 17.2 7.0 E. davisi Bird Bone Quarry F:AM 63001 15.9 6.5 E. davisi Bird Bone Quarry F:AM 63003 16.6 6.1 E. davisi Bird Bone Quarry F:AM 63008 16.9 6.3 E. davisi Bird Bone Quarry F:AM 63009a 15.5 6.4 E. davisi Bird Bone Quarry F:AM 63016b 16.2 6.7 E. davisi Bird Bone Quarry F:AM 63018 17.4 6.5 E. davisi Bird Bone Quarry F:AM 63019 17.7 7.1 E. davisi Bird Bone Quarry F:AM 63023 17.3 7.2 E. davisi Bird Bone Quarry F:AM 63026 17.3 6.6 E. davisi Bird Bone Quarry F:AM 63028 17.0 6.6 E. davisi Bird Bone Quarry F:AM 63028a 17.2 6.6 E. davisi Bird Bone Quarry F:AM 63029 17.2 7.5 E. davisi Bird Bone Quarry F:AM 63031 17.3 6.6 E. davisi Bird Bone Quarry F:AM 63038 17.3 7.2 E. davisi Bird Bone Quarry F:AM 63041 17.3 7.3 E. davisi Bird Bone Quarry F:AM 63042 17.7 7.0 E. davisi Bird Bone Quarry F:AM 63043 17.9 7.1 E. davisi Bird Bone Quarry F:AM 63045 18.1 7.5 E. davisi Bird Bone Quarry F:AM 63046 19.4 7.2 E. davisi Bird Bone Quarry F:AM 63056 19.1 7.5 E. davisi Bird Bone Quarry F:AM 72591 17.0 7.3 E. davisi Bird Bone Quarry F:AM 72592 18.5 7.6 E. davisi Bird Bone Quarry F:AM 72596 18.0 7.7 E. davisi Chamita fm. F:AM 27485 17.4 7.4 E. davisi Chamita fm. F:AM 49296 17.3 6.8 E. davisi Clay Bank Quarry F:AM 63009B 15.8 5.8 E. davisi Edson Local Fauna F:AM 49466 17.8 7.5 E. davisi Edson Local Fauna F:AM 49456 17.2 6.8 E. davisi Edson Local Fauna F:AM 49462 16.9 6.5 E. davisi Edson Local Fauna F:AM 49465 17.5 7.5 E. davisi Golgotha Water M.P. F:AM 49294a 16.5 6.3 E. davisi Gray’s Ranch F:AM 63043 18.7 7.1 E. davisi Littie Valley UO 26742 17.8 6.5 E. davisi Miami quarry F:AM 23353 16.9 6.5 E. davisi NE Oregon UOMNH F-3241 16.2 6.5 E. davisi Old Cabin quarry F:AM 72656 15.7 6.1 E. davisi Old Cabin quarry F:AM 75810 16.4 6.2 E. davisi Old Cabin quarry F:AM 75811 16.8 6.0 E. davisi Old Cabin quarry F:AM 75818 19.0 7.0 E. davisi Optima Local Fauna F:AM 62932 15.8 6.2 E. davisi Rentfro Pit F:AM 62981 18.9 7.1 E. davisi Yushe Basin F:AM 97031 17.1 6.8 E. davisi Yushe Basin F:AM 97058 17.5 6.8 E. davisi Yushe Basin F:AM 97060 16.9 6.9 E. davisi Yushe Basin THP 22757 18.0 E. debonisi Venta del Moro MNCN-VM 50 16.7 6.6 E. debonisi Venta del Moro MNCN-VM 51 16.9 6.6 E. debonisi Venta del Moro MGUV VV-14601 16.2 6.6 E. debonisi Venta del Moro MGUV 14753 14.7 5.8 E. debonisi Venta del Moro MGUV 14782 15 5.8 E. debonisi Venta del Moro MGUV VV-14788 15.4 6.6 E. debonisi Venta del Moro MGUV 14791 16 6.6 E. debonisi Venta del Moro MGUV VV-14793 17.2 6.5 E. debonisi Venta del Moro MGUV VV-15125 16 6.3 E. debonisi Venta del Moro MGUV 18473 16.6 6.3 E. debonisi Venta del Moro MGUV 18474 16.9 6.4 E. debonisi Venta del Moro MNCN71958 15 E. debonisi Venta del Moro MNCN71959 16.9 6.7 E. debonisi Venta del Moro MNCN71960 16.7 6.6 E. ferox Bird bone quarry F:AM 63035 19.9 8.1 E. ferox Bird bone quarry F:AM 63060 20.4 7.7 E. ferox Bird bone quarry F:AM 72606 19 7.8 E. ferox Golgotha Water Mill F:AM 49298 19.7 8.1 E. ferox Gray's Ranch quarry F:AM 63061 19.6 8 E. ferox Leyden Locality F:AM 27388 19.3 7.7 E. ferox Rancho San Martin FM 144232 18.6 7.4 E. ferox Redington quarry F:AM 75819 19.6 8.1 E. ferox Redington quarry F:AM 75821 22.8 9.4 E. ferox Redington quarry F:AM 75822 23.7 9.4 E. ferox Redington quarry F:AM 75848 21.8 8.6 E.' kuruksaensis Kuruksay AMNH 131867 19.3 7.5 E. marinae Muhur-Erig FM 1994-1 18.7 7.98 E. minor Beregovaja PIN 2975/7 19.3 7 E. minor Beregovaja PIN SN 19.6 7.2 E. minor Nihewan basin 10199 17.8 7.5 E. minor Nihewan basin THP 18731 17.4 6.9 E. minor Shamar GIN K970/15 16.7 7 E. minor Shamar PIN 3111/329 19.5 7.5 E. monticinensis Cava Monticino BRS 27/21 18.8 7.5 E. monticinensis Cava Monticino BRS 27/4 17.7 7.22 E. monticinensis Cava Monticino MSF 458 16.6 6.8 E. odessanus Alatini ALA-1 16.1 6.33 E. odessanus Odessa Catacombs AMNH 131865 18.4 6.8 E. odessanus Odessa Catacombs AMNH 131866 16.5 6.5 E. odessanus Odessa Catacombs PIN 390/160 17.2 6.5 E. odessanus Odessa Catacombs PIN 390/162 17.2 6.5 E. odessanus Odessa Catacombs PIN 390/163 18.4 7 E. odessanus Odessa Catacombs PIN 390/164 17.8 7 E. odessanus Odessa Catacombs PIN 390/165 18.7 7.2 E. odessanus Odessa Catacombs PIN 390/166 17 6.6 E. odessanus Odessa Catacombs PIN 390/167 19.5 7 E. odessanus Odessa Catacombs PIN 390/168 18 7 E. odessanus Odessa Catacombs PIN 390/169 17.3 6.7 E. odessanus Odessa Catacombs PIN 390/171 15.8 6.2 E. odessanus Odessa Catacombs PIN 390/172 16.1 6.3 E. odessanus Odessa Catacombs PIN 390/177 17.3 6.3 E. zhoui Yushe Basin F:AM 143864 17.4 7.3 E. zhoui Yushe Basin F:AM 97048 17.6 7.1 E. zhoui Yushe Basin THP 10199 17.8 7.5 Additional References Baryshnikov GF. 2011. Pleistocene Felidae (Mammalia, Carnivora) from the Kudaro paleolithic cave sites in the Caucasus. Proc Zool Inst Russ Acad Sci. 315:197-226. De Beaumont C, Mein P. 1972. Recherches sur le genre Plioviverrops Kretzoi (Carnivora, Hyaenidae). Arch Sci. 25:383-394. De Bonis L. 2005. Carnivora (Mammalia) from the Late Miocene of Akkasdagı, Turkey. Geodiversitas. 27: 567-589. Geraads D. 2016. Pleistocene Carnivora (Mammalia) from Tighennif (Ternifine), Algeria. Geobios. 49:445- 58. Peigné S. 2016. Carnivora. in Sen S. editor. Late Miocene mammal locality of Küçükçekmece, European Turkey. Geodiversitas. 38:197–224.