e3d57f2214f39a06011fcbe89831c854 Comparing_advice_on_climate_policy.pdf 6308a68efd8339447a7c2d803c2288d7b715ddde Comparing_advice_on_climate_policy.pdf f0e4025a8434b33cb8f64508532d0279efbe3ef4735aea40eb0cadd1e28f751e Comparing_advice_on_climate_policy.pdf Title: Comparing advice on climate policy between academic experts and ChatGPT Subject: Ecological Economics, 226 (2024) 108352. doi:10.1016/j.ecolecon.2024.108352 Keywords: Artificial intelligence,Chatbot,Experts,Climate policy,Survey Author: Foroogh Salekpay Creator: Elsevier Producer: Acrobat Distiller 8.1.0 (Windows) CreationDate: Sat Aug 24 01:16:16 2024 CEST ModDate: Sat Aug 24 01:19:33 2024 CEST Custom Metadata: yes Metadata Stream: yes Tagged: no UserProperties: no Suspects: no Form: none JavaScript: no Pages: 22 Encrypted: no Page size: 595.276 x 793.701 pts Page rot: 0 File size: 1523565 bytes Optimized: yes PDF version: 1.7 name type encoding emb sub uni object ID ------------------------------------ ----------------- ---------------- --- --- --- --------- GMMMCE+CharisSIL CID TrueType Identity-H yes yes yes 802 0 XWIAQE+CharisSIL-Bold CID TrueType Identity-H yes yes yes 807 0 HKTFXI+CharisSIL-Italic CID TrueType Identity-H yes yes yes 812 0 XGIGHM+TimesNewRomanPS-ItalicMT CID TrueType Identity-H yes yes yes 817 0 VOGVYH+TeX_CM_Roman Type 1C Builtin yes yes yes 822 0 PKPNKO+Univers Type 1C Builtin yes yes yes 826 0 YKZWTV+CharisSIL CID TrueType Identity-H yes yes yes 793 0 JQNIFZ+STIX-Regular Type 1C Custom yes yes yes 240 0 PMEQCY+TimesNewRomanPSMT CID TrueType Identity-H yes yes yes 245 0 HWIKBU+CharisSIL-Italic CID TrueType Identity-H yes yes yes 233 0 HVVCNJ+TeX_CM_Maths_Symbols Type 1C Builtin yes yes yes 254 0 GIKFTZ+STIX-Italic Type 1C Custom yes yes yes 271 0 Jhove (Rel. 1.28.0, 2023-05-18) Date: 2024-10-23 02:40:16 CEST RepresentationInformation: Comparing_advice_on_climate_policy.pdf ReportingModule: PDF-hul, Rel. 1.12.4 (2023-03-16) LastModified: 2024-09-21 09:58:44 CEST Size: 1523565 Format: PDF Version: 1.7 Status: Well-Formed, but not valid SignatureMatches: PDF-hul ErrorMessage: Invalid indirect destination - referenced object 's0010' cannot be found ID: PDF-HUL-149 ErrorMessage: edu.harvard.hul.ois.jhove.module.pdf.PdfInvalidException: Invalid indirect destination - referenced object 's0010' cannot be found ID: PDF-HUL-122 Offset: 1498388 MIMEtype: application/pdf Profile: Linearized PDF PDFMetadata: Objects: 894 FreeObjects: 1 IncrementalUpdates: 1 DocumentCatalog: PageLayout: SinglePage PageMode: UseOutlines Language: en Outlines: Item: Title: Comparing advice on climate policy between academic experts and ChatGPT Destination: mk:title Children: Item: Title: 1 Introduction Destination: mk:H1_1 Item: Title: 2 Responses from ChatGPT Destination: mk:H1_2 Children: Item: Title: 2.1 Policy performance criteria Destination: mk:H2_1 Item: Title: 2.2 Policy criteria Destination: mk:H2_2 Item: Title: 2.3 Policy instruments Destination: mk:H2_3 Item: Title: 2.4 Carbon pricing Destination: mk:H2_4 Item: Title: 2.5 General closing questions Destination: mk:H2_5 Item: Title: 3 Comparison with academic experts Destination: mk:H1_3 Children: Item: Title: 3.1 Policy performance criteria Destination: mk:H2_6 Item: Title: 3.2 Policy instruments Destination: mk:H2_7 Item: Title: 3.3 Carbon pricing Destination: mk:H2_8 Item: Title: 3.4 General closing questions Destination: mk:H2_9 Item: Title: 4 Additional questions to ChatGPT for deeper understanding of responses Destination: mk:H1_4 Children: Item: Title: 4.1 About consistency of responses Destination: mk:H2_10 Item: Title: 4.2 About information sources Destination: mk:H2_11 Item: Title: 4.3 About disciplinary sources Destination: mk:H2_12 Item: Title: 5 Conclusions Destination: mk:H1_5 Item: Title: CRediT authorship contribution statement Destination: mk:H1_6 Item: Title: Declaration of competing interest Destination: mk:HH1_2 Item: Title: Data availability Destination: datalink3 Item: Title: Acknowledgments Destination: mk:HH1_4 Item: Title: Appendix A Appendix Destination: mk:H1_7 Children: Item: Title: A.1 Software versions and dates of questioning Destination: mk:H2_13 Item: Title: A.2 Questions posed to, and answers by, ChatGPT Destination: mk:H2_14 Children: Item: Title: A.2.1 Questions from the survey Destination: mk:H3_15 Item: Title: A.2.2 Additional questions to assess potential inconsistencies Destination: mk:H3_16 Item: Title: A.2.3 Additional questions about information use Destination: mk:H3_17 Item: Title: References Destination: mk:HH2_1 Info: Title: Comparing advice on climate policy between academic experts and ChatGPT Author: Foroogh Salekpay Subject: Ecological Economics, 226 (2024) 108352. doi:10.1016/j.ecolecon.2024.108352 Keywords: Artificial intelligence,Chatbot,Experts,Climate policy,Survey Creator: Elsevier Producer: Acrobat Distiller 8.1.0 (Windows) CreationDate: Sat Aug 24 01:16:16 CEST 2024 ModDate: Sat Aug 24 01:19:33 CEST 2024 ID: 0x99db669b5c7b9213f90a32dda611268f, 0xd99b2ce7253f489a6868fc629044a28f Filters: FilterPipeline: FlateDecode FilterPipeline: DCTDecode Images: Image: NisoImageMetadata: FormatName: image/jpg CompressionScheme: JPEG ImageWidth: 236 ImageHeight: 298 BitsPerSample: 8 BitsPerSampleUnit: integer Image: NisoImageMetadata: FormatName: image/jpg CompressionScheme: JPEG ImageWidth: 248 ImageHeight: 271 BitsPerSample: 8 BitsPerSampleUnit: integer Fonts: Type0: Font: BaseFont: XGIGHM+TimesNewRomanPS-ItalicMT Encoding: Identity-H ToUnicode: true Font: BaseFont: GMMMCE+CharisSIL Encoding: Identity-H ToUnicode: true Font: BaseFont: PMEQCY+TimesNewRomanPSMT Encoding: Identity-H ToUnicode: true Font: BaseFont: XWIAQE+CharisSIL-Bold Encoding: Identity-H ToUnicode: true Font: BaseFont: HKTFXI+CharisSIL-Italic Encoding: Identity-H ToUnicode: true Type1: Font: BaseFont: JQNIFZ+STIX-Regular FontSubset: true FirstChar: 1 LastChar: 6 FontDescriptor: FontName: JQNIFZ+STIX-Regular Flags: Nonsymbolic FontBBox: -970, -486, 2208, 1023 FontFile3: true EncodingDictionary: BaseEncoding: WinAnsiEncoding Differences: true ToUnicode: true Font: BaseFont: VOGVYH+TeX_CM_Roman FontSubset: true FirstChar: 1 LastChar: 128 FontDescriptor: FontName: VOGVYH+TeX_CM_Roman Flags: Symbolic FontBBox: -50, -180, 1000, 720 FontFile3: true ToUnicode: true Font: BaseFont: PKPNKO+Univers FontSubset: true FirstChar: 32 LastChar: 251 FontDescriptor: FontName: PKPNKO+Univers Flags: Symbolic FontBBox: -50, -180, 1000, 720 FontFile3: true ToUnicode: true Font: BaseFont: HVVCNJ+TeX_CM_Maths_Symbols FontSubset: true FirstChar: 1 LastChar: 138 FontDescriptor: FontName: HVVCNJ+TeX_CM_Maths_Symbols Flags: Symbolic FontBBox: -50, -180, 1000, 720 FontFile3: true ToUnicode: true Font: BaseFont: GIKFTZ+STIX-Italic FontSubset: true FirstChar: 1 LastChar: 2 FontDescriptor: FontName: GIKFTZ+STIX-Italic Flags: Nonsymbolic, Italic FontBBox: -970, -305, 1429, 1023 FontFile3: true EncodingDictionary: BaseEncoding: WinAnsiEncoding Differences: true ToUnicode: true CIDFontType2: Font: BaseFont: XGIGHM+TimesNewRomanPS-ItalicMT CIDSystemInfo: Registry: Adobe Registry: Identity Supplement: 0 FontDescriptor: FontName: XGIGHM+TimesNewRomanPS-ItalicMT Flags: Nonsymbolic, Italic FontBBox: -498, -307, 1120, 1023 FontFile2: true Font: BaseFont: GMMMCE+CharisSIL CIDSystemInfo: Registry: Adobe Registry: Identity Supplement: 0 FontDescriptor: FontName: GMMMCE+CharisSIL Flags: Nonsymbolic FontBBox: -692, -533, 1623, 1319 FontFile2: true Font: BaseFont: PMEQCY+TimesNewRomanPSMT CIDSystemInfo: Registry: Adobe Registry: Identity Supplement: 0 FontDescriptor: FontName: PMEQCY+TimesNewRomanPSMT Flags: Nonsymbolic FontBBox: -568, -307, 2000, 1007 FontFile2: true Font: BaseFont: XWIAQE+CharisSIL-Bold CIDSystemInfo: Registry: Adobe Registry: Identity Supplement: 0 FontDescriptor: FontName: XWIAQE+CharisSIL-Bold Flags: Nonsymbolic, ForceBold FontBBox: -720, -533, 1759, 1320 FontFile2: true Font: BaseFont: HKTFXI+CharisSIL-Italic CIDSystemInfo: Registry: Adobe Registry: Identity Supplement: 0 FontDescriptor: FontName: HKTFXI+CharisSIL-Italic Flags: Nonsymbolic, Italic FontBBox: -716, -533, 1627, 1318 FontFile2: true XMP: application/pdf 10.1016/j.ecolecon.2024.108352 Elsevier B.V. Ecological Economics, 226 (2024) 108352. doi:10.1016/j.ecolecon.2024.108352 Artificial intelligence Chatbot Experts Climate policy Survey Comparing advice on climate policy between academic experts and ChatGPT Foroogh Salekpay Jeroen van den Bergh Ivan Savin journal Ecological Economics © 2024 The Author(s). Published by Elsevier B.V. 0921-8009 226 1 December 2024 2024-12-01 108352 108352 10.1016/j.ecolecon.2024.108352 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ecolecon.2024.108352 2010-04-23 true 10.1016/j.ecolecon.2024.108352 elsevier.com sciencedirect.com http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ VoR 10.1016/j.ecolecon.2024.108352 noindex 2010-04-23 true 24th August 2024 sciencedirect.com elsevier.com Elsevier 2024-08-23T23:19:33 2024-08-23T23:16:16 2024-08-23T23:19:33 True 24th August 2024 Acrobat Distiller 8.1.0 (Windows) Artificial intelligence,Chatbot,Experts,Climate policy,Survey uuid:1b499bed-4ce8-4c0c-b682-0d58baae1cbe uuid:b6ed5266-03cb-4855-90c0-636283357f42 1 https://www.elsevier.com/tdm/tdmrep-policy.json Pages: Page: Label: 1 Annotations: Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 123, 576, 245, 587 Flags: Print Destination: 778 Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 246, 576, 253, 587 Flags: Print Destination: 778 Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 254, 576, 259, 587 Flags: Print Destination: 778 Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 260, 571, 323, 582 Flags: Print Destination: 778 Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 323, 576, 330, 587 Flags: Print Destination: 778 Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 330, 576, 337, 587 Flags: Print Destination: 778 Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 337, 571, 342, 582 Flags: Print Destination: 778 Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 67, 169, 163, 177 Flags: Print Destination: 157 Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 167, 169, 264, 177 Flags: Print Destination: 201 Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 269, 169, 288, 177 Flags: Print Destination: 201 Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 37, 158, 127, 166 Flags: Print Destination: 201 Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 132, 158, 205, 166 Flags: Print Destination: 157 Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 435, 305, 502, 313 Flags: Print Destination: 157 Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 507, 305, 557, 313 Flags: Print Destination: 201 Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 306, 294, 324, 302 Flags: Print Destination: 201 Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 374, 273, 444, 281 Flags: Print Destination: 157 Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 491, 263, 552, 271 Flags: Print Destination: 201 Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 98, 104, 165, 111 Flags: Print Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 321, 722, 369, 730 Flags: Print Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 270, 667, 401, 675 Flags: Print Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 37, 87, 194, 94 Flags: Print Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 297, 749, 300, 757 Flags: Print Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 230, 748, 363, 760 Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 499, 616, 528, 645 Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 406, 57, 552, 69 Page: Label: 2 Annotations: Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 183, 730, 237, 738 Flags: Print Destination: 201 Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 40, 563, 119, 571 Flags: Print Destination: 157 Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 125, 563, 252, 571 Flags: Print Destination: 201 Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 116, 553, 170, 561 Flags: Print Destination: 201 Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 225, 511, 257, 519 Flags: Print Destination: null Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 37, 490, 69, 498 Flags: Print Destination: 22 Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 37, 479, 71, 487 Flags: Print Destination: 62 Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 252, 448, 288, 456 Flags: Print Destination: 93 Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 468, 439, 494, 447 Flags: Print Destination: 1 Page: Label: 3 Annotations: Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 262, 730, 288, 738 Flags: Print Destination: 1 Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 37, 720, 48, 728 Flags: Print Destination: 1 Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 72, 689, 98, 696 Flags: Print Destination: 16 Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 455, 511, 481, 519 Flags: Print Destination: 22 Page: Label: 4 Annotations: Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 442, 406, 557, 414 Flags: Print Destination: 22 Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 411, 364, 508, 372 Flags: Print Destination: 157 Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 513, 364, 557, 372 Flags: Print Destination: 157 Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 306, 354, 324, 362 Flags: Print Destination: 157 Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 497, 291, 523, 299 Flags: Print Destination: 36 Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 347, 165, 413, 173 Flags: Print Destination: 157 Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 514, 155, 557, 163 Flags: Print Destination: 201 Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 306, 145, 330, 153 Flags: Print Destination: 201 Page: Label: 5 Annotations: Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 499, 678, 520, 686 Flags: Print Destination: 36 Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 537, 542, 557, 550 Flags: Print Destination: 49 Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 462, 490, 557, 498 Flags: Print Destination: 157 Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 306, 479, 324, 487 Flags: Print Destination: 157 Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 443, 406, 514, 414 Flags: Print Destination: 157 Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 399, 291, 421, 299 Flags: Print Destination: 49 Page: Label: 6 Annotations: Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 465, 69, 492, 77 Flags: Print Destination: 1 Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 514, 69, 557, 77 Flags: Print Destination: 201 Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 306, 58, 324, 66 Flags: Print Destination: 201 Page: Label: 7 Annotations: Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 126, 657, 152, 665 Flags: Print Destination: 16 Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 223, 657, 285, 665 Flags: Print Destination: 201 Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 78, 553, 154, 561 Flags: Print Destination: 157 Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 171, 291, 198, 299 Flags: Print Destination: 36 Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 209, 291, 275, 299 Flags: Print Destination: 201 Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 127, 270, 153, 278 Flags: Print Destination: 36 Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 165, 270, 227, 278 Flags: Print Destination: 201 Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 405, 720, 425, 728 Flags: Print Destination: 62 Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 444, 678, 514, 686 Flags: Print Destination: 201 Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 339, 647, 366, 655 Flags: Print Destination: 36 Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 380, 647, 413, 655 Flags: Print Destination: null Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 377, 542, 437, 550 Flags: Print Destination: 157 Page: Label: 8 Annotations: Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 37, 259, 70, 267 Flags: Print Destination: 22 Page: Label: 9 Annotations: Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 176, 605, 203, 613 Flags: Print Destination: 84 Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 206, 396, 226, 404 Flags: Print Destination: 93 Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 130, 260, 136, 268 Flags: Print Destination: 84 Page: Label: 10 Annotations: Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 46, 309, 73, 317 Flags: Print Destination: 84 Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 309, 354, 374, 362 Flags: Print Destination: 157 Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 378, 354, 440, 362 Flags: Print Destination: 201 Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 457, 260, 557, 268 Flags: Print Destination: 201 Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 306, 249, 324, 257 Flags: Print Destination: 201 Page: Label: 11 Annotations: Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 313, 382, 375, 390 Flags: Print Destination: 157 Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 394, 382, 454, 390 Flags: Print Destination: 201 Page: Label: 12 Page: Label: 13 Page: Label: 14 Page: Label: 15 Page: Label: 16 Page: Label: 17 Page: Label: 18 Page: Label: 19 Page: Label: 20 Page: Label: 21 Annotations: Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 37, 152, 285, 159 Flags: Print Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 49, 144, 277, 151 Flags: Print Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 37, 136, 281, 143 Flags: Print Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 49, 128, 282, 135 Flags: Print Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 49, 120, 259, 127 Flags: Print Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 37, 112, 286, 119 Flags: Print Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 49, 104, 266, 111 Flags: Print Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 49, 97, 170, 103 Flags: Print Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 37, 89, 262, 95 Flags: Print Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 49, 81, 285, 87 Flags: Print Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 49, 73, 280, 79 Flags: Print Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 49, 65, 254, 71 Flags: Print Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 306, 173, 555, 179 Flags: Print Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 318, 165, 555, 171 Flags: Print Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 318, 157, 526, 163 Flags: Print Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 306, 149, 555, 155 Flags: Print Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 318, 141, 519, 147 Flags: Print Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 306, 133, 555, 139 Flags: Print Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 318, 125, 449, 131 Flags: Print Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 306, 117, 555, 123 Flags: Print Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 318, 109, 497, 115 Flags: Print Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 306, 101, 555, 107 Flags: Print Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 318, 93, 350, 99 Flags: Print Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 306, 85, 555, 91 Flags: Print Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 318, 77, 551, 83 Flags: Print Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 455, 61, 549, 67 Flags: Print Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 318, 53, 354, 59 Flags: Print Page: Label: 22 Annotations: Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 199, 716, 271, 722 Flags: Print Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 49, 708, 108, 714 Flags: Print Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 37, 700, 285, 706 Flags: Print Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 49, 692, 221, 698 Flags: Print Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 37, 684, 264, 690 Flags: Print Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 49, 676, 254, 682 Flags: Print Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 37, 668, 278, 674 Flags: Print Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 49, 660, 201, 666 Flags: Print Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 306, 732, 538, 738 Flags: Print Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 318, 724, 555, 730 Flags: Print Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 318, 716, 376, 722 Flags: Print Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 306, 708, 555, 714 Flags: Print Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 318, 700, 553, 706 Flags: Print Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 306, 692, 555, 698 Flags: Print Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 318, 684, 555, 690 Flags: Print Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 318, 676, 406, 682 Flags: Print Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 306, 668, 548, 674 Flags: Print Annotation: Subtype: Link Rect: 318, 660, 447, 666 Flags: Print Checksum: 0fbb72ba Type: CRC32 Checksum: e3d57f2214f39a06011fcbe89831c854 Type: MD5 Checksum: 6308a68efd8339447a7c2d803c2288d7b715ddde Type: SHA-1 Checksum: f0e4025a8434b33cb8f64508532d0279efbe3ef4735aea40eb0cadd1e28f751e Type: SHA-256